Where History Meets the Unexpected in Mule Alley

Caterina’s at Mule Alley may appear unassuming from the exterior, but once guests walk through the front door they’re immediately immersed in an energy that is one-of-a -kind. The space is slim, but the nostalgia is potent. Caterina’s takes the classic New York Italian joint and reimagines it in the 21st century with a menu that’s to die for and a design that pairs historic elements with modern touches for a fresh and inviting feel.

The lower level is intimate yet comfortable with thoughtful furniture details and silhouettes that are reminiscent of classic Italian furniture styles. The wall paneling isn’t traditional wood stained, but rather it’s painted with a saturated color to breathe life into the space. The mosaic tilework throughout takes vintage inspired black and white patterns of the 1920’s and reimagines them in unexpected ways. Seating at the bar is highly coveted since it’s fluid with the kitchen space and provides a level of entertainment that’s specific to the bar area. The mezzanine level is flexible for many uses but shines best as a unique private dining experience for larger parties. The arched metal and glass screening paired with the custom wine display create moments of discovery for guests as they travel from level 1 up the mezzanine.

Caterina’s at Mule Alley is sure to be an instant classic with a vibrancy that can’t be ignored and a level of design that is unmatched at Mule Alley.​